The
European Union SR2S project not only investigates the principles and
the scientific problems (of magnetic shielding), but it also faces the
complex issues in engineering.
Superconducting magnets, commonly found in MRI scanners, produce
stronger, more efficient magnetic fields using smaller and lighter
magnets than magnets made using conventional materials such as copper or
aluminium.
On earth, superconducting materials must be cooled to very low
temperatures using liquid helium to utilize their superconducting
properties, however the project has already found a solution that will
work in space.
‘We have decided to use a new superconducting material, discovered in
2001: magnesium diboride or MgB2,’ explained Dr Musenich. MgB2 can
superconduct at 10 kelvin, or -263 degrees Celsius, which removes the
need for liquid-helium cooling as this temperature is comparable with
that of deep space.
Simulations of the magnetic system suggest that a 10-meter-diameter
magnetic field could be produced by a system weighing less than half
that of a comparable passive shield.
The SR2S superconducting shield will provide an intense magnetic field,
3,000 times stronger than the Earth’s magnetic field and will be
confined around the space craft.
An active deflector shield system could never replace passive shielding or biological advances,
but it can offer options, particularly for EVAs, extending the
longevity of hardware and preventing secondary activation of the ship's
hull and systems. It seems the only credible theory for deflection of
GeV particles.
CERN will be helping to test the superconducting radiation shield design
NASA has a 158 page report on superconducting radiation shielding.
Magnetic fields with 10 tesla and 10 meters thickness could deflect
about 93% of the radiation. The EU design has overall protection against
50-70% of the radiation.
Author:
brian wang
on
8/22/2015
A superconducting shield to protect astronauts
The CERN Superconductors team in
the Technology department is involved in the European Space Radiation
Superconducting Shield (SR2S) project, which aims to demonstrate the
feasibility of using superconducting magnetic shielding technology to
protect astronauts from cosmic radiation in the space environment. The
material that will be used in the superconductor coils on which the
project is working is magnesium diboride (MgB2), the same type of conductor developed in the form of wire for CERN for the LHC High Luminosity Cold Powering project.
Back in April 2014, the CERN Superconductors team
announced a world-record current in an electrical transmission line using cables made of the MgB
2
superconductor. This result proved that the technology could be used in
the form of wire and could be a viable solution for both electrical
transmission for accelerator technology and long-distance power
transportation. Now, the MgB
2 superconductor has found
another application: it will soon be tested in a prototype coil that
could provide the solution to ensure safe trips for astronauts during
deep-space missions. The idea is to create an active magnetic field to
shield the spacecraft from high-energy cosmic particles. “In the
framework of this project, CERN is testing MgB
2 tape in a configuration that has specifically been developed for the
SR2S project by Columbus Superconductors,” explains Amalia Ballarino, Superconductors and Superconducting Devices section leader.
“In the framework of the project, we will test, in the coming months, a racetrack coil wound with an MgB2 superconducting
tape,” says Bernardo Bordini, coordinator of CERN activity in the
framework of the SR2S project. “The prototype coil is designed to
quantify the effectiveness of the superconducting magnetic shielding
technology.”
During
long-duration trips in space and in the absence of the magnetosphere
that protects people living on Earth, astronauts are bombarded with
high-energy cosmic rays that might cause a significant increase in the
probability of various types of cancers. Because of this, exploration
missions to Mars or other distant destinations will only become
realistically possible if an effective solution for adequately shielding
astronauts is found. “If the prototype coil we will be testing produces
successful results, we will have contributed important information to
the feasibility of the superconducting magnetic shield,” says Ballarino.
There are many more challenges
to overcome before a spacecraft shield can be built: various possible
magnetic configurations need to be tested and compared and other key
enabling technologies need to be developed. But the MgB2
superconductor seems to be very well-placed to take part in this
challenging adventure as, among its many advantages, there is also its
ability to operate at higher temperatures (up to about 25 K) thus
allowing the spacecraft to have a simplified cryogenic system. Watch
this “space”!
The SR2S Project
SR2S
is a Collaborative Project under the Space Theme of the EU Seventh
Framework Research Programme. The project started in January 2013 and
will end in December 2015. The aim of the SR2S project is to provide a
pathway for the further development of a protective shield for
astronauts, which should be launched in the market within the next two
decades.
Radiation Protection and Architecture Utilizing High Temperature Superconducting Magnets
Shayne Westover
NASA Johnson Space Center
Human space exploration exposes astronauts to particularly hazardous
environments unique from Earth-based hazards. A substantial risk for
exploration beyond the confines of the Earth’s geomagnetic field is
radiation exposure from energetic solar protons and Galactic Cosmic
Radiation. The concept of shielding astronauts with magnetic/electric
fields has been studied for over 40 years and has remained an
intractable engineering problem. Superconducting magnet technology has
made great strides in the last decade. Coupling maturing technology with
potential innovative magnet configurations, this proposal aims to
revisit the concept of active magnetic shielding. The focus of the
proposed work is to analyze new coil configurations with current
technology and compare shielding performance and design mass with
alternate passive shielding methods.
Space Radiation Superconducting Shield
– Space Radiation
Several space agencies and research
institutions around the world are conducting research into spacecraft
shielding technologies. These can be categorized into two basic types.
Passive shielding involves the use of some material that will absorb
incoming radiation. But they become impractically massive for shielding
against GCRs and would also break up the GCR into harmful secondary
radiation.
Active shielding uses electric or magnetic fields to deflect radiation and would be effective against both GCR and SEP.
Some of the leading work in active
radiation shielding is being undertaken by the Space Radiation
Superconducting Shield (SR2S). It is an EU-funded project whose aim is
“to develop, validate and increase the Technology Readiness Level (TRL)
of the most critical technologies related to a
magnetic shielding system for protecting astronauts’ lives during
long duration space missions.” The project, started in January 2013,
has received funding under the EU Seventh Framework Research Programme –
Space Theme and will run until December 2015. The participating
organizations include Italian Institute for Nuclear Physics (INFN),
Compagnia Generale per lo Spazio (CGS SpA), Columbus Superconductors,
Thales Alenia Space – Italia S.p.A. (TAS-I), Commissariat à l’énergie
atomique et aux énergies alternatives (CEA), CERN, and Carr
Communications.
The project is developing a shielding
system powered by a superconducting magnet that will deflect radiation,
similar to the Earth’s magnetosphere. Superconducting magnets generate
strong magnetic fields compared to traditional magnetic materials. But
superconductors work only at extremely low temperatures. SR2S plans to
overcome this problem by using
a new superconductor, magnesium diboride MgB2, which can operate at -263 Celsius and thus doesn’t require liquid helium cooling.
The SR2S project has conducted a study
on the feasibility of a superconducting magnetic shield, comparing the
various possible magnetic configurations and analyzing its merits as
well the challenges of this approach. It has also developed some key
enabling technologies required to build such a spacecraft shield. Other
major milestones include an assessment of the requirements for a super
conducting magnetic radiation shield and a realistic configuration to be
used in the short term to design demonstration units. Project partners
have also conducted review, analysis and selection of the requirements
on radiation doses for exploration travel in deep space.
Professor Roberto Battiston
Radiation shielding to protect a mission to Mars
The EU-funded SR2S project is developing magnetic
shielding that can deflect dangerous cosmic rays. Image: SR2S
Harmful
radiation comes from two main sources in space; low-energy protons
emitted from the sun, known as the solar wind, and much higher energy
particles known as galactic cosmic rays that originate outside the solar
system.
Long-term exposure to galactic cosmic rays and solar particles can
lead to a significantly higher risk of developing cancer, researchers
believe.
Increasing the thickness of spacecraft walls would be enough to
protect astronauts from low-energy particles from the sun, however
high-energy galactic cosmic rays would interact with the shielding
materials to produce even more radiation.
The EU-funded SR2S project is developing magnetic shielding instead
that can deflect these dangerous cosmic rays in the same way as the
earth’s magnetic shield protects humans from cosmic radiation.
The idea, originally proposed in 1969 by space engineer Wernher von
Braun, the so-called father of rocket science, is to use a
superconducting magnet to create the shield.
‘As the magnetosphere deflects cosmic rays directed toward the earth,
the magnetic field generated by a superconducting magnet surrounding
the spacecraft would protect the crew,’ said Dr Riccardo Musenich,
scientific and technical manager for the project.
‘SR2S is the first project which not only investigates the principles
and the scientific problems (of magnetic shielding), but it also faces
the complex issues in engineering.’
‘The magnetic field generated by a superconducting magnet surrounding the spacecraft would protect the crew.’
Dr Riccardo Musenich, scientific and technical manager, SR2S
Superconductors
The project will evaluate the feasibility of making such a shield by
the time it finishes at the end of 2015. To do this, it has turned to
superconductors, materials that have no electrical resistance at
extremely low temperatures, to help them solve one of the biggest
problems with a magnetic shield - the weight of the large magnet
required.
Superconducting magnets, commonly found in MRI scanners, produce
stronger, more efficient magnetic fields using smaller and lighter
magnets than magnets made using conventional materials such as copper or
aluminium.
On earth, superconducting materials must be cooled to very low
temperatures using liquid helium to utilize their superconducting
properties, however the project has already found a solution that will
work in space.
‘We have decided to use a new superconducting material, discovered in
2001: magnesium diboride or MgB2,’ explained Dr Musenich. MgB2 can
superconduct at 10 kelvin, or -263 degrees Celsius, which removes the
need for liquid-helium cooling as this temperature is comparable with
that of deep space.
Simulations of the magnetic system suggest that a 10-metre-diameter
magnetic field could be produced by a system weighing less than half
that of a comparable passive shield.
Habitats for extreme environments
Once the astronauts have arrived on Mars with both themselves and
their spacecraft intact, the thin atmosphere and weak magnetosphere
means they still won’t be safe from harmful radiation. Researchers on
the SHEE project are attempting to reduce the economic and human cost of
establishing outposts in the most inhospitable environments.
By identifying common architectural considerations for extreme
environments on earth and in space, the project will develop a
self-deployable living and working space, which includes a rigid section
to house life support systems, folding sections for workspaces and
robotic motors to aid with deployment.
Future versions of the SHEE habitat could also be used on earth,
providing shelters in areas recently hit by natural disasters, or mobile
laboratories in difficult-to-access environments. Initial construction
of a prototype began in April 2014 and a fully operational habitat
suitable for two people will be finished in 2016.
For details, visit
http://www.shee.eu/main
Shields up for manned space exploration
Thriving
settlements on Mars, mining operations on the moon, exploration teams
heading out into the universe — humankind may one day be able to
establish a presence far beyond its home planet. The EU-funded SR2S
project strives to remove one of the main obstacles by developing a
magnetic shield to protect astronauts from radiation in deep space.
Artistic representations of an active, magnetic, toroidal shield used for protecting astronauts from
astroparticles during the transfer in orbit
SR2S focuses on the use of
superconducting magnets to deflect dangerous radiation on manned
missions into deep space. It has developed a variety of innovative
components and technologies that are light, compact, energy-efficient
and reliable enough for such journeys.
The project’s advances include cutting-edge superconducting materials, a
novel approach to avoiding potentially destructive heat build-up in the
magnets, and a powerful system to cool the equipment on the side
exposed to the sun.
These breakthroughs are not just important for the future of manned
space exploration. They also stimulate innovation here on Earth.
Superconductors underpin technologies as diverse as magnetic resonance
imaging scanners and particle accelerators.
Deflecting radiation with magnets
The powerful ionising radiation in space is one of the main issues to
be tackled if humanity wants to head out into the starry void, says
project coordinator Roberto Battiston of Italy’s National Institute for
Nuclear Physics, who was appointed president of the Italian Space Agency
in May 2014. On Earth, we are sheltered — the atmosphere provides
radiation shielding equivalent to 3.5 metres of aluminium, in addition
to the protection offered by our planet’s shadow and magnetic field.
“Astronauts in deep space will receive a hundred times more radiation
than on Earth,” Battiston remarks. “This has not so far been a major
limitation for space exploration, because currently astronauts don’t
stay in deep space very long.” A return journey to Mars, which would
involve approximately one year in deep space, would be a different
matter entirely.
The concept of a magnetic shield is not new, says Battiston, but prior
to SR2S it had never been explored in detail. “This is the first
programme set up to tackle the various challenges of an active shield
for space,” he explains. “One possible approach is to build a magnet
that creates a field able to sweep the particles before they get into
the craft. Obviously that’s a challenge, but at the moment it’s the most
promising idea we have. SR2S is improving the technologies that are
needed for this idea to become a reality.”
Superconductors offer no electrical resistance to electrical currents
running through them, meaning these currents can be maintained without
access to a power source — an important consideration for applications
in space. That said, materials with superconducting properties only
display these at very low temperatures, which means that the magnets
have to be cooled.
Superconducting magnets are, of course, already widely used. However,
at the moment they are too large and too heavy to be of practical use in
space flight. SR2S has designed lighter, smaller components and systems
based on magnesium diboride, which offers the added advantage of being
far less costly than other superconducting materials.
The project has also developed the systems needed to keep these magnets
running: powerful cryogenics, an innovative system to dissipate excess
energy during transitions from superconductivity to normal conductivity,
and an array of light, small pipes that will move heat away from the
part of the hull that is exposed to the sun, towards the craft’s cooler
side.
Mars matters
The project will end in December 2015, but further development is
needed to prepare the technology for deployment, says Battiston. He
expects this final stage to take 10 to 20 years.
And then, in terms of the radiation shielding, it’s all systems go for
human exploration of our planetary neighbourhood. Without it, that’s not
an option, according to Battiston. “You can’t send people to Mars just
to have them die of cancer when they return to Earth,” he says.
SR2S is thus helping to ensure that we will eventually be able to
boldly go where no Earthling had ventured before. “Tackling such a
difficult problem is fascinating,” Battiston concludes. “It calls for
new ideas and new approaches to push the technologies to the extreme.
This kind of challenge is an extraordinary technology driver, which
first and foremost benefits applications on Earth.”
Below artistic representations of an active, magnetic, toroidal
shield used for protecting astronauts from astroparticles during the
transfer in orbit viewed from the top (fig.2) and viewed in perspective
(fig.3)

© SR2S / Image: Giorgina Colleoni & Valerio Calvelli
Braking Against a Stellar Wind
This morning I want to pick up on the ‘problem of arrival’ theme I
began writing about on Friday, and we’ll look at interstellar
deceleration issues a good bit this week. But I can’t let Monday start
without reference to the Icarus results from Gran Sasso that finds
neutrinos traveling at precisely the speed of light. All of this adds
credence to the growing belief that the earlier Opera experiment was
compromised by equipment problems. The news is all over the place (you
might begin with this BBC
account)
and while we’ll keep an eye on it, I don’t plan to spend much time this
week on neutrinos. We still have much to get done on the subject of
slowing down.
Magsails and Local Resources
When you begin to unlock the deceleration issue, the options quickly
multiply, and you find yourself looking into areas that weren’t remotely
the subject of your earlier research. As we saw on Friday, the concept
of magnetic sails grew organically out of Robert Bussard’s idea of an
interstellar ramjet. Bussard didn’t want to slow down — he wanted to go
very fast indeed. Read the comments on that post and you’ll find Al
Jackson’s entertaining reminiscences of a dinner with Bussard (
Tau Zero
author Poul Anderson was present too), and a reminder that the
scientist always claimed to have come upon the ramjet idea because of an
encounter with Mexican food. The usual story has it that it was a
burrito which, bitten down upon, suddenly opened for Bussard the
splendors of matter being forced into a cylinder at high speeds.
Or maybe he was eating
huevos rancheros — the story seems to
have varied a bit over the years. Whatever the case, the idea of
scooping up interstellar hydrogen and fusing it turned into a 1960 paper
for
Acta Astronautica and, along the way, into a critique by
Robert Zubrin and Dana Andrews that showed just how much drag an
electromagnetic scoop could generate. Andrews was working for Boeing at
the time, and had grown interested in using Bussard concepts right here
in the Solar System, thinking that a big enough scoop could gather
hydrogen for use in an ion engine that could be powered up by an onboard
nuclear reactor. A self-fueling ion drive might not be adaptable for
interstellar missions, but for interplanetary work it seemed worth a
look.
But the numbers were intractable. The magnetic scoop Andrews hoped to
deploy created more drag than the ion engines produced thrust. The two
researchers quickly found that the scoop’s best function was as a
magnetic sail, and their work on the idea appeared in the literature in
the early 1990s. In his 1999 book
Entering Space, Zubrin
recalls that the time was right for the magsail given that Paul Chu
(University of Houston) had just invented the first high-temperature
superconductors, which a magsail could theoretically use to create the
magnetic field that would allow it to ride on the solar wind. Practical
high-temperature superconducting wire born out of this work might one
day allow magsails to achieve higher thrust-to-weight ratios than solar
sails.
Magsails have clear propulsion implications, but Zubrin states the obvious about their most effective uses:
…the most interesting and important thing about the
magsail is not what it can do to speed up a spacecraft — what’s
important is its capability for slowing one down. The magsail is the
ideal interstellar mission brake! No matter how fast a spaceship is
going, all it has to do to stop is deploy and turn on a magsail, and the
drag generated against the interstellar plasma will do the rest. Just
as in the case of a parachute deployed by a drag racer, the faster the
ship is going, the more ‘wind’ is felt, and the better it works.
Which takes us to the idea of using in-situ resources to tackle the
deceleration problem. If your goal is to launch a starship that can
decelerate in the destination system to explore it, the magsail lets you
do the job without carrying the deceleration fuel aboard the vehicle.
Play around with the numbers long enough and you’ll see what a huge
boost this would be, for otherwise you’re carrying all the fuel needed
to slow down a starship (moving, perhaps, at .10
c!), and that
means you’ve got to get all of that fuel up to cruise in the first
place. The idea of creating drag against the interstellar medium and a
destination stellar wind thus has a powerful appeal.
Rise of the Superconductor
When Bussard studied how his ramjet could operate in a region of
interstellar space where the density of hydrogen was roughly 1 hydrogen
atom per cubic centimeter, he saw that he would need a collecting area
of 10,000 square kilometers. This is so vast that even if it were made
of 0.1-centimeter mylar, a physical scoop would weigh something on the
order of 250,000 tons. But a much smaller collector generating a
magnetic field seems practical given the advances in superconducting
alluded to above, with a loop of superconducting wire deployed from the
spacecraft, the current applied to it cycling continuously to generate
the magnetic field. Here’s how Zubrin and Andrews described it in a
paper based on their presentation at the 1990 Vision-21 symposium at
NASA’s Lewis Research Center (now Glenn Research Center):
The magnetic sail, or Magsail, is a device which can be
used to accelerate or decelerate a spacecraft by using a magnetic field
to accelerate/deflect the plasma naturally found in the solar wind and
interstellar medium. Its principle of operation is as follows: A loop of
superconducting cable hundreds of kilometers in diameter is stored on a
drum attached to a payload spacecraft. When the time comes for
operation the cable is played out into space and a current is initiated
in the loop. This current once initiated, will be maintained
indefinitely in the superconductor without further power. The magnetic
field created by the current will impart a hoop stress to the loop
aiding the deployment and eventually forcing it to a rigid circular
shape.
Image: A space probe surrounded by a magnetic sail.
Early work
on these concepts has taken place at the University of
Washington
under Robert Winglee, with reports available at NASA’s
Institute
for Advanced Concepts
site. Credit: NASA/University of Washington.
Thus the hybrid concept Andrews and Zubrin came up with in the
Vision-21 work, extending ideas they had first presented in a 1988
paper: Use laser beaming technology to push a sail to interstellar
cruise speeds, then deploy a magsail upon arrival to reduce deceleration
time. The authors looked at the numbers and worked out 0.8 years for
acceleration, 17.4 years of coasting at almost half the speed of light,
and 18.8 years for deceleration. This gets you about 10 light years out
in around 37 years, a mind-bending pace that uses a huge sail and some
generous assumptions about laser power that we’ll look at tomorrow. For
there are other ways to use lasers, even for deceleration, and other
ways, too, to exploit the local interstellar medium.
Zubrin and Andrews’ paper from Vision-21 is “Use of Magnetic Sails
for Advanced Exploration Missions,” in the proceedings of Vision-21:
Space Travel for the Next Millennium” (NASA Conference Publication
10059. The citation for their 1988 work is given in yesterday’s
Centauri Dreams post.
